top of page

A Theory of Everything # 16 'The art therapy sessions 5'

Writer: Mark Stock
Mark Stock
5 days ago
5 min read


‘Supervision is vital for professional growth, ethical accountability, and client safety.’ - https://counsellingtutor.com/models-of-supervision/


‘Supervision is a formal process in which a qualified or trainee psychotherapist or psychotherapeutic counsellor regularly presents his or her client work to a designated or chosen supervisor as way of enhancing their practice through careful reflection on the process.’ - https://www.psychotherapy.org.uk/ukcp-members/supervision/

 

Perhaps the most significant entries made by Sally Mungall into her clinical notes were those associated with ‘supervision’.

 

‘21st October, 2021  Events 03P Arts Therapy

‘Mark has shown that he is very moved by the perceived care within the room. At times objectifies, and idolises and idealises therapist. Also at times, eye contact is very unsettling in nature.

Therapist reminds him often that this space provides a therapeutic relationship to support the care of Meg and her treatment and that I am not his friend, nor am I his mother, punisher or girlfriend.

Mark told me that he would never hurt me and that it upset him to that I might be scared.

Therapist Will continue to discuss in supervision . --- 25 Oct 2021 12;30, Sally Mungall’

 

The entries made on the 21st October, 2021, are ALL contentious and require examination but, for the purpose of this post, I will focus on the final line, ‘Therapist Will continue to discuss in supervision.’


Sally Mungall makes a statement that explicitly confirms that she is already in dialogue with a therapeutic supervisor, discussing her ongoing work with me, even though there are no references to ‘supervision’ in any of her previous clinical notes. More so, there are multiple entries throughout the remainder of Sally Mungall’s clinical notes referring to ‘supervision’. This revelation is truly staggering.


The frequency and implied intensity of supervision sought by Sally Mungall in my case has been identified as a serious concern by all of the psychotherapists who I have worked with since. Sally Mungall evidently struggled to maintain objectivity and effectiveness in therapy.

Medical records suggest that Sally Mungall relied on the same ‘supervisor’ throughout. That ‘supervisor’ was Amanda Parke.


Those same medical records suggest Amanda Parke was another member of the CAMHS team working at Bramblys Drive, Basingstoke, which means that Sally Mungall was relying on a peer to provide objective ‘supervision’. Peer supervision is not necessarily an inferior mode of supervision. Indeed, most of the academic literature I have read supports the use of peer supervision as a supplement to more traditional modes of supervision.


‘Peer supervision differs from more traditional forms of supervision in that it does not require the presence of a more qualified, identified expert in the process - the supervisor, and the supervision process emphasizes critical and supportive feedback while deemphasizes evaluation. Its use can be a viable alternative or supplement to traditional supervision and can offer a variety of benefits traditional supervision doesn’t usually provide.’ - https://www.academia.edu/40819099/Peer_Supervision_in_the_Therapeutic_Field


However, the sole reliance on this type of supervision is NOT without it’s fair criticism. The same academic paper cited above goes further.


‘Challenges in peer supervision include discomfort with providing feedback and potential negative group dynamics.’


A more concerning academic appraisal is referred to here;


 ‘4 WORRYING WEAKNESSES In addition to being an illogical concept and an empirically unsupported method, the lack of monitoring in PGS, together with the reliance on discussion, severely limit the opportunities to judge whether clinical practice is safe and effective. This was demonstrated recently by incompetence and fatal misjudgements (Department of Health, 2016). In this sense, PGS neglects to provide staff with proper support and guidance. Similarly, PGS is somewhat fraudulent, implying that supervision is in place when it is not. Consequently, PGS members may jeopardize their professional registration. There is a related ‘imposter’ aspect, in that the supervisors in PGS are not trained to supervise. Yet, PGS participants risk vicarious clinical liability, as in law this flawed arrangement may be regarded as supervision (Saccuzzo, 1997).’ - https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1111/jan.13413I


Was Amanda Parke trained to supervise?


Amanda Parke has always remained conspicuously absent from the public record. There is no clear link online that identifies Amanda Parke as the person working at CAMHS, Bramblys Drive, Basingstoke between September and December, 202. She is not to be found on any national database that lists psychodynamic professionals and certainly not registered as a ‘supervisor’ with any organisation including the UK Council for Psychotherapy or the British Association for Psychoanalytic and Psychodynamic Supervision.


So. Who exactly was providing Sally Mungall with clinical supervision?


‘Clinical supervision is a key concept that many people are unclear about. Unclear whether 'supervision' means that you should be ensuring that the supervisee is 'doing it right' or whether you should be providing a sounding board for the supervisee to develop their clinical thinking, or what. And many people are equally unsure about exactly what their professional body has to say about it, and where to find that out.’ - https://www.apt.ac/clinical-supervision-training-course.html


CLINICAL ABUSE


Sally Mungall did actually draw attention to the fact that she had discussed me in supervision. She raised the subject towards the beginning of one particular session of ‘art therapy’ in the wider context of ‘clinical abuse’. According to Sally Mungall, both she and her supervisor had considered that the therapy being delivered had turned abusive. She wanted my opinion, asking ‘Did I agree that the therapy was abusive?’  and ‘Did I want it to stop?’


REALLY?


The mental health professional with access to supervisory oversight lays responsibility of consent to a client who is already overwhelmed, compromised and vulnerable.

I have raised the clinical abuse story with many mental health professionals since. Most have expressed profound incredulity.


How was it that Amanda Parke failed to provide the prerequisite level of oversight needed to ensure ethical practice and client safety?


Did Amanda Parke understand the true nature of the therapeutic relationship she was supervising?

 

Sally Mungall’s clinical notes written more than a month later would suggest that her objective competence had no improved. Again, she discusses my case with supervisor, Amanda Parke.

 

25th November, 2021  Events  04 Care Plan Review   03P Arts Therapy


Other staff: Amanda Parke

‘Case discussed in supervision.

Mark (dad)s desire to merge is the driving force

Does not have any understanding of the healthy connected relationship

Others are always treated as aspects of themselves

Has to be a part of the other or he is not

Needing to tease self out

Therapist becoming confused in thinking, but there is much difference between. Need to be clearer where the edge of self and other is.’ --- 25 Nov 2021 15.10, Sally Mungall


'Therapist becoming confused in thinking, but there is much difference between. Need to be clearer where the edge of self and other is.’

Comments


bottom of page